Camp X-Ray stands out as a unique film that takes a slow-burning, character-driven approach to one of the most controversial aspects of modern American history—the indefinite detention of suspected terrorists. While the movie does not take an overtly political stance, it does critique the dehumanization that occurs in such high-security institutions.

Kristen Stewart’s performance is widely praised, with critics highlighting her ability to convey subtle emotional turmoil. The film’s strength lies in its dialogue-heavy storytelling, which allows for rich character development. However, some reviews criticize its predictability and occasional lapses into sentimentality.

IGN praised the film for its deep character study and emotional weight but noted that some of its messaging felt forced at times. Meanwhile, TheWrap and Slant Magazine argued that the relationship between Cole and Amir felt more like a scripted contrivance than an organic connection​.

Overall, Camp X-Ray is an emotionally charged drama that invites the audience to reflect on themes of duty, humanity, and the cost of war. It may not be a flawless film, but its performances and themes leave a lasting impact.