Old Henry (2021), directed by Potsy Ponciroli, is a taut, character-driven Western that breathes new life into the genre while paying homage to its classic roots. Led by a standout performance from Tim Blake Nelson, the film offers a slow-burning narrative rich in atmosphere and moral complexity.
Set in 1906, the story follows Henry, a reclusive widowed farmer raising his teenage son, Wyatt, in the Oklahoma Territory. Their quiet life is disrupted when Henry discovers a wounded man named Curry near their home, along with a satchel of cash. As Curry claims to be a lawman pursued by outlaws, Henry faces a dilemma: protect his family by turning Curry away or offer him shelter and risk attracting danger. The ensuing events unravel secrets from Henry’s past, culminating in a tense and violent confrontation.
Tim Blake Nelson delivers a nuanced portrayal of Henry, capturing the character’s internal struggle and stoic resilience. His performance anchors the film, conveying depth and authenticity. The supporting cast, including Scott Haze as Curry and Gavin Lewis as Wyatt, complement Nelson’s lead with solid performances.
Ponciroli’s direction emphasizes restraint and atmosphere, allowing the tension to build organically. The cinematography captures the stark beauty of the frontier, enhancing the film’s immersive quality.
Old Henry received widespread acclaim, holding a 94% critic score and a 92% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics praised its storytelling and Nelson’s performance, with RogerEbert.com highlighting the film’s “beautifully shot” scenes and Nelson’s “textured and nuanced” acting. The Hollywood Reporter described it as a “well-crafted exercise in old-fashioned but durable genre tropes” that evolves into a “satisfying reflection on the more complicated, somber realities behind the icons of the Wild West.”
Old Henry stands out as a compelling Western that combines classic genre elements with strong character development. Tim Blake Nelson’s performance elevates the film, offering a portrayal that is both understated and powerful. While it may not reinvent the Western, its execution and emotional depth make it a noteworthy entry for fans of the genre.