The Other Man attempts to be a tense psychological thriller but often feels more like a slow-burn mystery without enough payoff. The non-linear storytelling structure, shifting between Peter’s investigation and flashbacks of Lisa’s secret life, creates suspense but also leads to pacing issues. Neeson delivers a solid performance as a man consumed by doubt and anger, while Banderas plays Ralph with a mix of charm and ambiguity.

The film struggles with its tone, often feeling like a mix between a romance and a thriller without fully committing to either. Some critics felt that the emotional weight of the story was diluted by a lack of real tension, making it less gripping than intended. However, the performances of the lead actors add a degree of depth to an otherwise underwhelming script.

While The Other Man explores interesting themes of love, loss, and deception, it ultimately fails to deliver a satisfying resolution, leaving many viewers feeling unfulfilled. For fans of slow-burning dramas with strong performances, it may still be worth a watch.

Rating: ★★☆☆☆ (2.5/5)

Would you like recommendations for similar films with a stronger emotional impact?