The Tank delivers an eerie, tension-filled horror experience reminiscent of classic creature features. While its plot treads familiar ground, the film succeeds in crafting a moody and visually striking atmosphere. The Oregon coastline setting—actually shot in New Zealand—adds to the foreboding tension, complemented by strong cinematography and an effective use of practical effects​

The performances from Buchanan and Whelan are a highlight, bringing authenticity to their roles as a married couple trapped in an escalating nightmare​.

The creature itself, designed by the renowned WETA Workshop, is one of the film’s biggest strengths. However, some of its movements and abilities stretch believability, with critiques noting its inconsistent biological traits​.

The film’s climax is intense but somewhat restricted by a limited cast, making it hard to build suspense through character stakes. Additionally, the ending, which sees the survivors simply drive away, is viewed as abrupt, missing an opportunity for a more satisfying resolution​.

Despite these flaws, The Tank is a solid entry in the creature horror genre. Fans of practical effects-driven horror and atmospheric thrillers will find much to enjoy, though those looking for groundbreaking storytelling may be left wanting​.